Hello dear
Welcome To Island Bay Pier House
Island Bay Pier House, located at 110 State St in Clayton, NY, offers a cozy dining experience with a warm atmosphere and friendly service. Renowned for its delicious seafood, particularly the standout fish fry and clam chowder, it caters to diverse palates with off-menu specials and gluten-free options. Guests rave about the generous portions and reasonable prices, making it a cherished find, especially during the off-season. The attentive staff, including the welcoming hostess and dedicated servers, ensures a smooth dining experience. Whether for a casual meal or a special occasion, Island Bay Pier House is a must-visit destination for food lovers.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Island Bay Pier House
Welcome to Island Bay Pier House, a gem nestled in the picturesque town of Clayton, New York. Conveniently located at 110 State St, this charming eatery boasts a welcoming atmosphere that instantly feels like home. With its friendly staff and cozy decor, it's the perfect spot for food enthusiasts and casual diners alike.
Reviewers praise Island Bay Pier House for its stellar service and delicious menu. One visitor, C Fish, highlights the "friendly waitress" and notes how clean and comfortable the establishment is. This commitment to cleanliness and hospitality creates an inviting environment that makes you feel valued and relaxed. Cat D. echoes this sentiment, describing Island Bay as a "cozy little find" with reasonable prices and generous portions, while also noting the delightful sweetness of their Moscato—a refreshing choice to complement any meal.
One of the standout features of Island Bay Pier House is its vast selection of culinary delights that cater to various dietary preferences, including gluten-free options. Jessica Ridley can’t help but rave about the “fish fry” that has become a crowd-favorite. The excitement around the chef's off-menu specials adds an element of surprise, encouraging repeat visits. Many patrons, like SiQing Xu McDonnell, have found classic comfort foods like clam chowder and Caesar salad on the menu, showcasing a blend of tradition and creativity. Though someone found the salad a tad salty, the overall sentiment is one of satisfaction, especially regarding the fish, which has captured the hearts—and stomachs—of many.
The atmosphere at Island Bay Pier House is often noted by guests, with Sean Mansfield remarking on its quaint charm. This cozy ambiance, combined with the delicious seafood offerings, makes it a must-visit destination, especially for those exploring the scenic Alexandria Bay area. As you step into this delightful establishment, you’re met with the tantalizing aromas wafting from the kitchen, a precursor to the culinary experience that awaits.
If you seek a memorable dining experience filled with friendly service, great food, and a relaxing atmosphere, look no further than Island Bay Pier House. Make it a priority on your next visit to the area—you won’t regret it!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great restaurant. Friendly waitress. Good food. Nice bar area. Clean. Bathrooms were nice also ”
“ This was a cozy little find we stumbled on when we visited Alexandria Bay during the off season. Prices were reasonable and portions were huge! Food was absolutely delicious and I loved their Moscato (super sweet, crisp and lightly carbonated). They have the option to serve a round to the kitchen staff- which I definitely recommend after the food we received. Our server was Tay and even with a packed house we felt attended to and everyone who worked there, worked to keep things running smoothly. The hostess was super friendly and attentive as well! ”
“ Holy Good Food Batman. How have I passed this place for years and never stopped?!?!? All this time lost eating sub-par food when I could have eaten here!!! I love the options. I love that there are off menu specials. Gluten free is also offered which is a big deal to my family. The fish fry is so amazing! In fact it was so good we went back the next night and got take out! Do yourself a favor, eat here! You won’t regret it. Best food in the area hands down! My kids even loved it too! ”
“ This was a nice little spot. We came here after a long day of driving. They had a good selection of food and the food is good. I loved my clam chowder. The Caesar salad was a bit intense though, a bit too salty. And the croutons were interesting. But the salad was still good though. The fish was excellent. ”
“ Super quaint restaurant. I'm only in the area about once a year but I'll definitely be making this place a priority when I visit again. Some of the best clam chowder I've ever had and has such an amazing atmosphere and feel. A must go to if you're in the area. ”
“ An excellent Friday night fish fry! The haddock was pristine, white and incredibly flaky, fried to perfection in a house beer batter. And the house made tartar sauce was delectable! We shared an order of fried cheese curd and those were simply yummy, and came with both marinara and a sweet chili sauce. Who know how yummy sweet chilly sauce was on fried cheese? Not this girl! Well I do now, and I'm hooked! Nice friendly staff, and a great value! ”
“ Great food and service. The wings were excellent, and the spaghetti squash, chicken, and spinach entree was exceptionally good. Our server was friendly and efficient. We were in the larger dining room. However, the beautiful bar was an impressive sight. No complaints from our party of five. Can't wait to try other items on the extensive menu. ”
“ Went to dinner with the wife. I had fish and chips(Haddock), she had steak fettuccine. Everything was prepared perfectly and tasted delicious. Our server Shannon was top notch. Don't live in the area, but this will definitely be a stop for us everytime we come. UPDATE 9-17-22: Guess what? Food is still just as good as the 1st time, 2nd, 3rd,etc. Jordan the server was awesome. When we're in the area, we always stop. ”